Next.js vs Gatsby in 2025: Is Gatsby Still Relevant?
Gatsby was the go-to static site generator before Next.js fully embraced SSG. In 2025, Next.js handles everything Gatsby does — with far more flexibility. Here's when Gatsby might still make sense.
My recommendation
The verdict
Next.js for all new projects. Gatsby made sense before Next.js added ISR and strong SSG support. Today, Next.js does everything Gatsby does with the added benefit of SSR, API routes, and Server Components. Migrate existing Gatsby projects to Next.js for better long-term support and a more active ecosystem.
When to pick
Choose Next.js when
- Any new project — Next.js has superseded Gatsby for all use cases
- You need both static and server-rendered routes in the same app
- You want a single framework for marketing site and authenticated dashboard
- Active ecosystem and long-term framework investment matter
When to pick
Choose Gatsby when
- Existing Gatsby project where migration cost isn't justified
- Gatsby plugins already solve specific requirements (image processing, data sourcing)
- Your team is Gatsby-expert and the project scope is limited
Side by side
Next.js vs Gatsby: feature comparison
| Criterion | Next.js | Gatsby | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| SSG support | Excellent — generateStaticParams | Excellent — Gatsby's core feature | Both |
| SSR support | Full — App Router, Server Components | Limited — Gatsby is primarily static | Next.js |
| API routes | First-class — Route Handlers and Server Actions | Limited — Gatsby functions | Next.js |
| Build speed | Fast with Turbopack | Can be slow on large sites | Next.js |
| Plugin ecosystem | npm ecosystem — larger | Gatsby plugin system — mature but stagnating | Next.js |
| Active development | Very active — Vercel investment | Acquired by Netlify — slower development | Next.js |
Scenarios
Which to choose for your use case
New marketing site with CMS
Next.js + Sanity/Contentful is the modern pattern — better ISR and no GraphQL data layer complexity.
Existing Gatsby site that's working
Don't migrate a working site for its own sake — only migrate when you hit Gatsby's limitations.
FAQ
Common questions
Should I migrate from Gatsby to Next.js?+
If your Gatsby site is working well, there's no urgent need. When you hit Gatsby's limitations (SSR, dynamic routes, API routes), Next.js is the clear migration target.
Next step
Need help choosing?
I've built projects in both Next.js and Gatsby. Tell me what you're building and I'll give you a specific recommendation.